[ARTICLE]Medical Device

Utilizing Examiner Interviews to Further Prosecution in Medical Device Patent Applications

ServiceMedical device patents
  • Published
  • Updated
  • 6 min read
Utilizing Examiner Interviews to Further Prosecution in Medical Device Patent Applications

An examiner’s interview can be immensely beneficial when working through patent prosecution at the USPTO for your medical device invention. Below we cover when to request one, what it can accomplish and how to prepare, because you only get as much out of an interview as you put into it.

What Is a Patent Examiner Interview?

An examiner interview is a conversation between the applicant, usually through a patent attorney, and the examiner reviewing your medical device patent application. It can be held by phone, by video conference hosted by the USPTO, or in person. Interviews are common practice and are encouraged by the USPTO: its examining manual calls them “often indispensable” to moving an application forward.

When Should You Request an Examiner Interview?

Interviews can be requested at most stages of the prosecution of the patent. Most requests come after the first Office Action, which is often a good time, but every case is unique and the right moment depends largely on the nature of the rejection(s) in that Office Action.

A few timing rules apply. Before the first Office Action, a patentability interview is held only in a continuing or substitute application or when the examiner decides it would advance prosecution. Normally one interview is allowed after a final rejection, and after an appeal brief is filed or a notice of allowance is mailed, only in unusual circumstances.

Sometimes there are better ways to respond to a rejection than an interview. If the rejection is based on prior art, a claim amendment may be the better response, or argument and explanation in the Response may be enough to move prosecution forward. Either way, the interview can be saved for a later point in prosecution, when it might have more impact.

To request an interview, your attorney can call the examiner or submit the USPTO’s online Automated Interview Request (AIR) form through Patent Center. Examiners aim to respond to AIR requests within two business days.

Advantages of Examiner Interviews in Medical Device Patent Applications

Conducting an examiner interview has two main advantages. First, it increases the chances of success by giving you an opportunity to educate the examiner and, hopefully, reach an agreement on patentability. Second, it speeds up prosecution, because both you and the examiner come away clearer on what the invention is, what the most relevant prior art is, and how the two differ. A request for an interview also gains the attention of the assigned examiner, which is often the key to getting a patent processed.

[RLG]Free strategy call

Andrew Rapacke

Talk it through with a registered patent attorney.

Free 15 to 45 minute IP strategy call, no obligation.

The Purpose of Examiner Interviews

In general, the purpose of the examiner interview is threefold:

  1. The interview should provide information, legal and technical, to the examiner, which might help overcome the grounds for rejection.
  2. The interview should allow you to obtain information from the examiner that might help you provide more effective arguments in the Response.
  3. If possible, the interview should attempt to reach an agreement with the examiner that overcomes one or more issues set forth in an Office Action.

For example, if the rejection is based on prior art, the interview should aim to overcome it with more evidence and more information from the inventor. If the examiner then agrees the claim overcomes the cited prior art, the interview has succeeded. Even so, the examiner runs a final update search before allowance that can surface new art, so an agreement reached in an interview is not a guarantee of allowance.

How to Prepare for an Examiner Interview

Send A Detailed Agenda in Advance

The USPTO offers an Interview Best Practices guide for examiner interviews. In addition to filing form PTOL-413A, which states the goal of the interview and briefly summarizes the arguments to be presented, it is considered among the “best practices” to prepare a detailed Interview Agenda and send it as far ahead of the interview as possible, even if the examiner does not ask for one. A good agenda names the claims, figures and sections of the specification to discuss, plus any proposed amendment, so the examiner can prepare in about 20 to 30 minutes. Agendas can be sent by email or fax. Email and video contact with the examiner require an authorization for internet communications, which is built into the AIR form or can be filed on Form PTO/SB/439.

What Else Should be Sent in Advance of the Interview?

Since one main purpose of an interview is to reach an agreement with the examiner concerning patentability, where applicable, it may be useful to send review copies of:

  • A draft of the applicant’s proposed Response (a complete, formal response is not required before the interview).
  • Any and all proposed amendments to the specification, claims and drawings, if any.
  • References to be discussed during the interview.
  • Additional evidence to be discussed.
  • A summary of the arguments to be presented (if not already part of the detailed Agenda).

Sending these items in advance gives the examiner an opportunity to review them, which makes for a well-organized interview and better use of your time. Keep in mind that the USPTO keeps agendas and proposed amendments in the official record however they are sent, so draft them with care.

Who Should Attend the Interview?

Form PTOL-413A also asks for a list of “Tentative Attendees.” Guidance on who should attend should be taken from the Office Action. If the only issues are legal and procedural, then maybe only legal counsel needs to attend. If the issues are technical, the inventor and technical experts should also attend: bring the “witnesses” who will best help convince the examiner and overcome grounds for rejection. Your attorney should also have your authority to accept a reasonable range of proposals, since examiners normally interview only someone with negotiating authority. The Best Practices guide suggests that the applicant should be prepared to explain during the interview:

  • The “inventive concept” of the invention.
  • How the inventive concept is captured in the claim(s).
  • Any differences between the prior art of record and the claim(s).
  • How the claim(s) are distinguished over the prior art.
  • “Real world” applications of the claimed invention to assist in enhancing the examiner’s understanding of the claimed invention.

Should You Bring Anything to the Interview?

The attorney should bring any and all evidence, documentary and demonstrative, that will be most helpful in persuading the examiner. In the medical device art, it is typical for applicants to bring a working prototype of the device, or a video and photos if the prototype is too large. In a video conference interview, you can share your screen to show annotated figures, slides or animations. If practical, a demonstration is often useful to explain the differences between the invention and the prior art, especially if you can bring the prior art device along with your medical device.

“Witnesses” Should be Thoroughly Prepared for Interviews

Examiner interviews should be treated with as much seriousness as a more formal administrative or legal hearing, so prepare and practice with your “witnesses.” Practice reduces stress, and it keeps witnesses focused on their purpose: reaching an agreement with the examiner by addressing the stated reasons for rejection. The Best Practices guide cautions applicants to “limit unnecessary detail” and notes that “collaboration is more effective than argument, especially in the short time available.”

Completing the Interview Summary

After the interview, the examiner records its substance on an Interview Summary (form PTOL-413). The applicant must also make the substance of the interview of record, usually in the next reply, unless the examiner notes on the PTOL-413 that this is not necessary. The USPTO does not recognize agreements that are not in the written record, so reserve a few minutes at the end of the interview to agree on what the summary should say.

Conduct an Examiner Interview with The Rapacke Law Group

If you would like to discuss how an examiner interview could help your patent application, contact a patent attorney at The Rapacke Law Group. We have held many examiner interviews and know how to make the most of our time with examiners. Call us at 954-951-0154 or reach us by completing this online contact form.

  • examiner interview
  • medical device patent
  • patent application
  • patent examiner
  • uspto

[RLG]Free strategy call

Andrew Rapacke

Have an invention to protect?

Talk it through with a registered patent attorney.

  • 15 to 45 minute IP strategy call
  • A straight answer on what to protect first
  • A flat-fee quote, with no obligation

Client rating4.7From 614 public reviews

You build what’s next. We make it yours®

The #1 top reviewed IP law firm.* Talk to a registered patent attorney, free.

*#1 top reviewed means the most public client reviews on Google, Trustpilot and Avvo of any US patent or trademark firm.