The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) is not an infallible government entity, and from time to time the Patent Office might make a mistake by granting a patent in error. When this happens, other third-party entities, such as the patent holder’s competitors, may be miffed. When someone other than a patent holder has reason to believe that a patent was issued in error, they have legal recourse through an Inter Partes Review (IPR) challenge.
What Is IPR?
IPR is an opportunity for anyone who is not a patent holder to challenge the validity of an issued patent before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) at the USPTO. IPR is a particularly handy form of legal action for businesses that want to see their competitors’ patents rendered unusable, and for those entities who stand accused of infringement.
In patent law, IPR stands for inter partes review. It is not an infringement claim but a challenge to whether the patent should have been granted, and claims that are cancelled cannot be enforced.
In order to take advantage of an IPR challenge, there are specific timing rules that must be followed. Specifically, an IPR petition can be filed after the later of either nine months after the contested patent was issued, or after the termination of a Post Grant Review proceeding, which is another form of post-allowance patent review that occurs before the PTAB. An additional timing requirement applies to those IPR petitioners who are facing infringement litigation. An IPR must be filed within one year after the petitioner (or a real party in interest or privy) is served with a complaint alleging infringement of the patent.
How to Invalidate a Patent Through IPR
To invalidate a patent through IPR, you file a petition with the PTAB showing, with earlier patents or printed publications, that one or more claims were not new or were obvious. If review is instituted, a panel of administrative patent judges holds a trial and issues a final written decision. Claims it finds unpatentable are cancelled once any appeal ends.
Other routes exist. A Post Grant Review can raise almost any invalidity ground, but only in the first nine months after the patent issues. In an ex parte reexamination, the challenger files a request and then largely drops out, while inter partes review is a trial between the parties.
The IPR Process, Step by Step
Petition. Identify each challenged claim, the prior art and supporting declarations, and every real party in interest, and pay the USPTO fees.
Discretionary denial briefing. Since 2025, the patent owner may file a brief within two months of the notice of filing date asking for denial on non-merits grounds, such as parallel litigation, and the petitioner may oppose.
Preliminary response. The patent owner may respond on the merits within three months of the notice of filing date.
Institution decision. Within three months after that response, the USPTO decides whether there is a reasonable likelihood the petitioner will prevail on at least one claim. Since October 20, 2025, the USPTO Director makes this call, usually in a short summary notice, and it cannot be appealed.
Trial. A three-judge PTAB panel oversees limited discovery, further briefing, any motion to amend the claims, and an oral hearing.
Final written decision. It is due within one year of institution, extendable by up to six months for good cause.
IPR can be immensely beneficial if it is used effectively as part of a thorough and well-planned IP strategy. Consider the following advantages of IPR over litigation:
IPR Petitions Offer The Challenger A Procedural Choice. IPR offers challengers a choice between having the PTAB review the contested patent or having the District Court review the contested patent.
IPR Is Likely More Favorable To The Challenger. IPR is usually more favorable to a challenger than the courts can be. For instance:
In an IPR there is no presumed validity of the contested patent, whereas judges and juries presume that a patent that is issued by the USPTO is valid.
IPR once used a broader claim construction standard (the broadest reasonable interpretation) than the courts. Since November 13, 2018, the PTAB has used the same ordinary and customary meaning standard as the courts, so this particular advantage no longer applies.
There is a lower burden of proof for invalidity in an IPR than in litigation. IPR only requires a preponderance of the evidence standard, while the Court requires the clear and convincing evidence standard.
IPR Is Usually A Quicker Path to Invalidity. Statutory deadlines mean most IPRs are decided about 18 months after filing. Litigation, on the other hand, can last for years on end.
IPR Is Oftentimes More Affordable Than Litigation. The costs associated with IPR are more easily determined ahead of time based on the number of contested patents under IPR challenge, whereas litigation costs are likely to be very high and unpredictable. USPTO fees for challenging up to 20 claims total $51,875, paid with the petition. For a fuller picture, see whether an IPR is worth the cost.
How Often Do IPR Challenges Succeed?
In fiscal year 2026 (October 2025 to September 2026), the PTAB instituted 41% of the IPR and Post Grant Review petitions it decided, down from 50% in fiscal 2025 and 68% in fiscal 2024. Most of the drop came from discretionary denials: 56% of petitions screened by the Director were denied before the merits were reached, while 77% of those decided on the merits were instituted. Of the fiscal 2026 petitions that reached a final written decision:
About 61% ended with every claim at issue held unpatentable.
About 17% ended with some claims held unpatentable and others upheld.
About 22% ended with every claim at issue upheld.
In October 2025 the USPTO proposed barring IPR of claims already upheld by a court or the PTAB, or when a parallel case is likely to decide validity first. Those rules were not final as of November 2026, so check the current requirements before filing.
Do Not Abuse the IPR Process
Using IPR to harass a competitor, to needlessly delay a related court case, or simply to drive up the patent owner’s costs is an abuse of the process. The PTAB is authorized by statute to sanction misconduct, from excluding evidence to awarding attorney fees or entering judgment against the offending party.
Atlanta Gas Light Co. v. Bennett Regulator Guards, Inc. (IPR2015-00826) is a cautionary tale for any IPR petitioner. Its parent holding company became a subsidiary of The Southern Company before the final written decision, and Atlanta Gas did not tell the PTAB, which sanctioned it. Petitioners have a duty to keep the PTAB informed of who their real parties in interest are, and the PTAB takes this requirement seriously.
Need Help Filing An IPR? Speak With an IPR Attorney.
If you are interested in filing an IPR against your competitor or a patent holder that is accusing you of infringing activity, the IPR lawyers at The Rapacke Law Group are ready to help. Please contact us today to schedule a free initial consultation with one of our attorneys.
Inter Partes Review
IPR
patent
uspto
[RLG]Free strategy call
Not sure what to protect first?
Talk it through with a registered patent attorney.
Just like any other aspect of filing a patent application or a petition with the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), there are certain timing restrictions…
Ever since its introduction in 2012 with the enactment of the America Invents Act, Inter Partes Review (IPR) petitions have been a popular alternative, or tangential…
One of the most daunting aspects of an Inter Partes Review (IPR) proceeding at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) is the high cost. But the cost of an IPR often…
Read the article
You build what’s next.We make it yours®
The #1 top reviewed IP law firm.* Talk to a registered patent attorney, free.