[ARTICLE]Trademark Infringement

I’ve Been Threatened with a Trademark Infringement Lawsuit! What Do I Do?

ServiceTrademark litigation
  • Published
  • Updated
  • 4 min read
I’ve Been Threatened with a Trademark Infringement Lawsuit! What Do I Do?

It is all too common of a nightmare scenario: a small business or individual receives a cease and desist letter accusing them of unauthorized use of a trademark and threatening trademark infringement litigation if use of the alleged trademark does not stop immediately. Sometimes these letters will include an offer to license the trademark in question.

Receiving a letter like that can be scary, and it can threaten the ongoing success of your business. Many recipients don’t know what to do next. Below is some helpful guidance on how to handle a situation where you stand accused of trademark infringement.

Step 1: Get in Touch with A Trademark Infringement Lawyer

The first thing you need to do is take your cease and desist letter to an experienced trademark infringement lawyer. After your lawyer has an opportunity to review the letter, your attorney can answer any questions you have, such as:

  • What are trademarks? What is infringement?
  • Is the mark you are using too similar to the mark you are accused of infringing?
  • Do you have a priority claim to the mark in question?
  • Do you have to agree to the licensing offer that was made to you in the letter?

It is important to take your letter to an attorney as soon as possible so that you can get a full understanding of your current legal situation and so that you can discuss what legal options are available to you in your particular circumstances.

The legal options available to you will depend on a number of factors. Trademark rights exist in different forms: rights based on common law, state law, and federal law. Depending on the type of rights tied to the trademark you are accused of infringing, there will be different ways to respond to the allegations. Your lawyer can discuss each option with you and help you choose an approach that is right for you and your business.

Step 2: Take Action and Respond to the Letter

Once you have discussed your situation with a lawyer, you should be ready to make an informed decision about how to respond to the letter. Perhaps you believe that you have a priority claim to the trademark based on your lengthy history of use of the mark in commerce. Or perhaps you believe that you are the rightful, registered owner of the trademark, or think that the mark you are using is not confusingly similar to the mark you are accused of infringing. In these situations, you would take action to contest the alleged infringement. You could also use mediation, or enter into negotiations with the accusing party to work out a deal where you can keep using the mark. If that doesn’t work, you can always seek resolution of the matter through litigation.

On the other hand, you might not be sure what you are infringing, and you can request clarification of the matter from your accuser. You could also opt to take a wait-and-see approach by doing nothing. Finally, if you are absolutely in the wrong, you could stop using the trademark in question immediately before you make the situation worse.

What Are the Defenses to Trademark Infringement?

The main defenses to trademark infringement are that buyers are not likely to confuse the two marks, that you used your mark first, that the other side’s mark is invalid or abandoned, or that your use is legally permitted, such as fair use or some parodies. Which defenses fit depends on the facts.

Some of these are affirmative defenses: you admit the trademark was used without permission but show a valid legal excuse for that use. Even against a registration that has become incontestable, the Lanham Act keeps defenses such as abandonment, descriptive fair use, prior use in a limited area, functionality, laches, estoppel, and acquiescence (15 U.S.C. § 1115(b)).

Affirmative Defenses to Trademark Infringement

  • Nominative use, or nominative fair use, of a trademark. You may generally use another company’s mark only to refer to its product, for example in comparative advertising or to say that your product is compatible with, or intended for use with, the trademarked product, as long as you do not suggest the owner sponsors you.
  • Descriptive fair use. If a mark is made up of ordinary descriptive words, others may still use those words in good faith, and not as a brand, to describe their own goods or services or where they come from (15 U.S.C. § 1115(b)(4)).
  • Use of a trademark for the purpose of parody. Parody can help, but it is not an automatic defense. In Jack Daniel’s Properties v. VIP Products (2023), the Supreme Court held that when a parody of another company’s mark is used as the brand for one’s own product, courts apply the ordinary likelihood-of-confusion test, and the Lanham Act’s noncommercial-use exclusion does not block a dilution claim. A parody that clearly mocks the original is still often less likely to confuse buyers. Using a mark inside an expressive work, such as a piece of artwork, rather than as a brand on goods generally gets more room.

Affirmative Defenses in a Trademark Opposition

In an opposition before the USPTO’s Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, the applicant pleads its defenses in its answer. The rules allow affirmative defenses such as unclean hands, laches, estoppel, acquiescence, fraud, mistake, and prior judgment (37 C.F.R. § 2.106(b)). Delay-based defenses like laches rarely work there, because the delay generally cannot start running until the application is published for opposition.

Contact The Rapacke Law Group Today

If you need more information about trademark infringement or need help dealing with a cease and desist letter, contact an experienced and skilled trademark attorney at The Rapacke Law Group. RLG can be reached at 954-951-0154 or by completing this online contact form.

  • infringement
  • litigation
  • trademark

[RLG]Free strategy call

Andrew Rapacke

Not sure what to protect first?

Talk it through with a registered patent attorney.

  • 15 to 45 minute IP strategy call
  • A straight answer on what to protect first
  • A flat-fee quote, with no obligation

Client rating4.7From 614 public reviews

You build what’s next. We make it yours®

The #1 top reviewed IP law firm.* Talk to a registered patent attorney, free.

*#1 top reviewed means the most public client reviews on Google, Trustpilot and Avvo of any US patent or trademark firm.